Just lately, I spoke with a head of HR for a tech firm who requested: “Are you listening to of different organizations eliminating the supervisor position? Our CEO thinks they received’t be wanted sooner or later due to AI, as a result of the long run is self-managing groups.” Apart from the plain level that CEOs saying this can be speaking themselves out of a job, it’s not a uncommon query in any respect.
There’s even a reputation for this—the “Nice Flattening”—and it’s in every single place. Some 41% of workers say their firms trimmed administration layers final yr, in accordance with Korn Ferry’s survey of 15,000 professionals worldwide. Center managers accounted for more than 31% of all layoffs in 2023. And it’s not prone to cease, however to speed up as an alternative: Gartner predicts that via 2026, 20% of organizations will use AI to flatten their construction, eliminating over half of their center administration positions.
I get the attraction. Layers of administration are costly, and dangerous managers do exist. And if AI can take the notes, draft the objectives, schedule the one-on-ones, and flag the underperformers in a dashboard, what precisely is the human within the center for?
{“blockType”:”mv-promo-block”,”information”:{“imageDesktopUrl”:”https://pictures.fastcompany.com/picture/add/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2026/01/i-169-Ashley-Herd.jpg”,”imageMobileUrl”:”https://pictures.fastcompany.com/picture/add/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2026/01/i-11-Ashley-Herd.jpg”,”eyebrow”:””,”headline”:”u003Cemu003EThe Supervisor Methodu003C/emu003E”,”dek”:”Need sensible management improvement coaching that really sticks? Go to managermethod.com to study extra and order Ashley Herd’s guide, u003Cemu003EThe Supervisor Methodu003C/emu003E.”,”subhed”:””,”description”:””,”ctaText”:”Be taught Extra”,”ctaUrl”:”http://managermethod.com”,”theme”:{“bg”:”#2b2d30″,”textual content”:”#ffffff”,”eyebrow”:”#9aa2aa”,”subhed”:”#ffffff”,”buttonBg”:”#3b3f46″,”buttonHoverBg”:”#3b3f46″,”buttonText”:”#ffffff”},”imageDesktopId”:91478992,”imageMobileId”:91478994,”shareable”:false,”slug”:””,”wpCssClasses”:””}}
Right here’s what I’d say to that CEO, having spent years as an employment lawyer cleansing up the messes that dangerous administration creates, and in addition in HR roles watching what nice administration really produces: The query isn’t whether or not we’d like managers. It’s whether or not we’re prepared to confess how a lot worth they convey, and the burden they’re already carrying.
The quantity no one can argue with
Gallup’s research has one discovering that each CEO ought to have taped to their monitor: Managers account for a minimum of 70% of the variance in worker engagement scores throughout enterprise models.
Seventy %. It’s not perks, and even phrases {that a} CEO says in an all-hands. It’s the individual your workforce member reviews to that controls the overwhelming majority of how a lot effort they select to place into their work.
And engagement isn’t a gentle metric. Gallup has linked it to buyer scores, profitability, productivity, high quality, turnover, absenteeism, theft, and security incidents. Every little thing an govt really cares about runs via the supervisor layer. So when a CEO asks, “Can we even want managers?,” what they’re actually asking is: “Can we minimize 70% of the variance in our outcomes and hope it goes the correct manner?”
That’s an enormous wager.
The place the work really goes
We’ve run this experiment earlier than. Corporations have tried this, with completely different names: flat constructions, Holacracy, “self-management.” Over a decade in the past, Zappos famously eliminated the manager role and supplied workers the chance to remain or take a buyout. Inside a yr, 210 employees (14%) of their workforce took the buyout—however solely 20 of these had been managers, that means that 190 particular person contributors voluntarily determined to go away. And within the years after, Zappos ran into “big challenges” and introduced managers again. Medium, one other early adopter of the identical self-management mannequin, later abandoned it when the system began taxing its workforce’s effectiveness and sense of connection.
The sample is nearly at all times the identical. If you take away the supervisor, you don’t take away administration. You simply redistribute it. And the information’s now catching as much as that: After flattening, senior executives are absorbing extra direct reviews and operational duties, making the people doing the roles query their potential to really do these jobs.
The work didn’t disappear—however the accountability and training did. Excessive-potential workers aren’t studying learn how to make robust calls anymore—and the management disaster from that received’t present up till about two years after the cuts.
Within the AI model of this fantasy, it’s worse. As a result of now the “supervisor” is a dashboard. Your efficiency is scored, and any suggestions is a abstract.
I’ve sat in—and heard about—sufficient exit interviews to inform you what workers really say once they depart: “No one instructed me what was anticipated.” “I didn’t really feel like I mattered.” “I had no concept if I used to be doing a superb job or about to get fired.” None of these get solved by an algorithm. They get solved by a human who is aware of your title, your pet’s title, and what you’re making an attempt to construct, on this job and your profession.
What human workforce members really undergo
Org charts and spreadsheets don’t present what really results in engagement.
The excessive performer who used to remain late simply returned from maternity depart. She’s nursing within the parking zone between conferences and is satisfied she’s now failing at her job and being a mother.
The workforce member who obtained not-so-great biopsy outcomes for his mom final Tuesday didn’t share the information with you. He simply confirmed up at 9 a.m. Zoom assembly along with his digicam off.
The workforce member who’s been quiet currently is making an attempt to carry it collectively as a result of her closest work good friend simply received laid off. And he or she’s balancing the guilt of nonetheless having a job with the stress of being anticipated to do the job of two individuals now.
You’re an actual a part of these individuals’s lives. Not in a saccharine, “we’re a household right here” manner. (As an employment lawyer, I’d extremely encourage you not to say that.) However within the precise, measurable sense that the way you deal with a 30-second dialog will have an effect on whether or not they sleep tonight—and the work they do all yr.
That isn’t a job for synthetic intelligence, nor a job somebody can do alone.
The enterprise case individuals really need
I do know what issues most in a boardroom, so let me translate.
A supervisor who can learn the room and have the arduous dialog prevents the lawsuit. (I’ve seen numerous lawsuits that began with: “Nicely, no one ever really instructed her that her efficiency was an issue.”)
A supervisor who provides clear suggestions prevents the regretted attrition. The actual-talk model is a human considering, “My boss is nice—why would I ever depart?” Now image the alternative: the individual whose supervisor by no means confirmed as much as their one-on-one, so that they spent that point updating their résumé as an alternative. The price of changing an worker runs wherever from half to 2 occasions their wage, relying on the position. Multiply that by the turnover a disengaged—aka résumé-updating—workforce produces, and the “costly center layer” pays for itself earlier than lunch.
A supervisor who really develops individuals produces the subsequent layer of leaders. And the pipeline is already thinning: Deloitte research discovered that solely 6% of Gen Zers say attaining a management place is their major profession aim. That’s what occurs once they watch center managers get eradicated for effectivity and conclude the trail isn’t value it. AI is great at many issues. It doesn’t develop a 24-year-old right into a 34-year-old who can run a P&L.
The CEOs asking whether or not we’d like managers are normally asking the incorrect query. The best query is: Do we have now the correct managers—and have we really skilled them?
Gallup’s analysis can be clear on this: Corporations miss the mark on excessive managerial expertise in 82% of their hiring choices. We promote one of the best particular person contributor and count on that sole qualification to empower them to efficiently lead their groups, with out really giving them coaching to take action. Then we’re shocked once they can’t handle and get so pissed off that they depart.
The reply isn’t fewer managers. It’s better-supported ones: individuals who know learn how to set expectations, give suggestions, deal with the moments that matter, and drive outcomes with out driving their workforce out the door.
In case you’re a supervisor studying this, right here’s what I need you to remove: Your job is likely one of the most consequential roles in trendy work. And should you’re a CEO, right here’s your takeaway: This isn’t theoretical analysis—it’s your actual enterprise outcomes. Loads of firms have already run this experiment and discovered the lesson the arduous manner. You may pay full worth for it, or study it totally free. Both manner, the human on the opposite aspect of your subsequent one-on-one is relying on you—whether or not they say so or not.
{“blockType”:”mv-promo-block”,”information”:{“imageDesktopUrl”:”https://pictures.fastcompany.com/picture/add/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2026/01/i-169-Ashley-Herd.jpg”,”imageMobileUrl”:”https://pictures.fastcompany.com/picture/add/f_webp,q_auto,c_fit/wp-cms-2/2026/01/i-11-Ashley-Herd.jpg”,”eyebrow”:””,”headline”:”u003Cemu003EThe Supervisor Methodu003C/emu003E”,”dek”:”Need sensible management improvement coaching that really sticks? Go to managermethod.com to study extra and order Ashley Herd’s guide, u003Cemu003EThe Supervisor Methodu003C/emu003E.”,”subhed”:””,”description”:””,”ctaText”:”Be taught Extra”,”ctaUrl”:”http://managermethod.com”,”theme”:{“bg”:”#2b2d30″,”textual content”:”#ffffff”,”eyebrow”:”#9aa2aa”,”subhed”:”#ffffff”,”buttonBg”:”#3b3f46″,”buttonHoverBg”:”#3b3f46″,”buttonText”:”#ffffff”},”imageDesktopId”:91478992,”imageMobileId”:91478994,”shareable”:false,”slug”:””,”wpCssClasses”:””}}
