Free speech for me, not for thee.
That’s the oldest trick within the hypocrite’s playbook. And over the previous few weeks, Republicans and Democrats have each taken a web page from it.
Witness current occasions at Rutgers College following the homicide of Charlie Kirk, the conservative activist who based Turning Level USA. The group’s Rutgers chapter circulated a petition demanding that the college fireplace historical past professor Mark Bray for his alleged hyperlinks to antifa, a left-wing anti-fascist motion.
“Having a outstanding chief of the antifa motion on campus is a risk to conservative college students,” the petition warned, noting that Bray had “usually referred” to “mainstream conservative figures” as fascists. “That is the form of rhetoric that resulted in Charlie Kirk being assassinated.”
By no means thoughts that Kirk himself insisted that folks “must be allowed to say outrageous issues,” as he told the Oxford Union earlier this yr. “There’s ugly speech. There’s gross speech. There’s evil speech. And all of it’s protected by the First Modification,” Kirk posted on social media in 2024.
And by no means thoughts the time-honored right-wing criticism about “cancel tradition” on American campuses. For years, conservatives have charged that universities censored them by imagining speech as violence. In case you opposed affirmative motion, for instance, you have been threatening nonwhite college students. We have to shield them from hurt, the argument went, so we’re shutting you down.
Now conservatives are turning that very same argument in opposition to figures akin to Bray. “Within the present political local weather, it’s paramount to guard college students from radicals who want violence upon them,” the Rutgers Turning Level petition claims, explaining why Bray must be dismissed.
Bray is a scholar of antifa however denies being a member of the group, which President Donald Trump’s administration not too long ago called a “home terrorist group.” It’s not clear that antifa — a extremely decentralized motion — qualifies as an “group” in any respect. And even when it does, civil rights attorneys have claimed, Trump lacks any authorized authority to designate it as “terrorist.”
However the GOP has turn into the social gathering of cancel tradition, and Trump is the canceller-in-chief. In January, after returning to the White Home, Trump issued an order restoring free speech to the nation.
He then embarked upon a wide-ranging campaign of censorship, particularly in opposition to universities.
The White Home revoked the visas of scholar protesters, penalized faculties for allegedly antisemitic speech, and pressured them to wash web sites of any language associated to range, fairness and inclusion. And on the College of Pennsylvania, the place I educate, we have been forced to apologize for letting a trans feminine swimmer compete on the ladies’s group.
You may suppose that an assault of this magnitude would trigger the American left to make a full-throated protection of free and open expression. However you’d be mistaken.
Certain, Trump’s victims have condemned him for trampling on their free speech rights. However they’ve additionally demanded the censorship of right-wing voices, together with — you guessed it — Turning Level USA.
At Rutgers, for instance, almost 7,000 individuals signed a petition asking the college to disband its Turning Level chapter as a result of its allegedly violent rhetoric made individuals really feel unsafe. “It’s crucial that we take decisive motion to revive safety and the sensation on inclusivity to the campus,” the petition urged. “The protection and well-being of our college students and school have to be prioritized.”
Sound acquainted? It’s nearly precisely what Turning Level stated about Bray. He’s utilizing harmful phrases, so we have to shut him down.
Nobody has confronted extra hazard than Bray. After Turning Level demanded his dismissal — and Fox Information picked up the story — Bray obtained a number of dying threats, inflicting him to flee the country along with his household. That’s horrible, after all, but it surely’s hardly a sound cause to close down Turning Level. You may simply as nicely censor Bray for the homicide of Kirk, whose murderer made references to fascism.
Let’s be clear: No one must be allowed to make direct threats of bodily hurt, akin to Bray suffered. However as soon as we determine to censor speech on the grounds that it would trigger violence — or make somebody afraid — we gained’t be capable of communicate in any respect.
Alas, that’s a lesson we nonetheless refuse to be taught. After Rutgers sought to remove two leaders of its Turning Level chapter — as a result of, the college stated, they weren’t registered as officers of the group — they denounced the transfer as a “politically motivated” assault on their freedom of speech. “We would like differing values, we would like totally different beliefs, we need to have conversations with individuals,” stated Ava Kwan, one of many scholar leaders.
However Bray was a special story, Kwan insisted. He must be fired as a result of he has praised antifa, and antifa has promoted violence. “We don’t really feel protected on campus with him round,” Kwan claimed. “We don’t really feel protected having him appointed at Rutgers.”
In different phrases: Free speech for me, not for thee. And if that’s what you imagine, you don’t imagine in free speech. You simply need your individual aspect to win.
©2025 Chicago Tribune. Go to at chicagotribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
