President Donald Trump and his administration insist their warfare of selection in Iran bears zero similarity to the bitter Iraq Warfare the U.S. plunged into 23 years in the past. I disagree.
Each wars have been based mostly on lies about imminent threats from nuclear weapons to justify wars of selection. In 2003, the intelligence on Saddam Hussein’s nuclear program was cherry picked and false. In 2025, Trump himself advised People that Iran’s nuclear program had been “obliterated” by U.S. and Israeli airstrikes in June, and there’s no proof that Tehran is ready to reconstitute this system — so there was no “imminent risk” to America.
The brand new White Home line that Israeli strain prompted Trump’s resolution to bomb has already been rejected by the president (though it could include a number of kernels of reality).
In 2003 as immediately, the U.S. president had bother clarifying the strategic targets of the warfare. Not like George W. Bush, Trump denies he seeks “regime change” (after calling for it). However then as now, there was little to no preparation for “the day after” the warfare ends. (Trump said Thursday he ought to be concerned in selecting Iran’s subsequent supreme chief.)
Such lack of imaginative and prescient — or ample self-delusion — propelled People to catastrophe in Iraq, even with some competent advisers within the White Home. As Trump directs coverage solo, based mostly on whim and ill-informed whispers from Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, it’s onerous to see a contented ending in Iran.
But, having lined the 1991 Gulf Warfare and the 2003 Iraq Warfare (in all its phases by way of 2017), what I discover most tragic is the potential for unusual Iranians to be harmed as badly by Trump as Iraqis have been harm by Bush’s warfare.
Few Iranians will mourn the demise of the merciless and murderous Ayatollah Khamenei or his cohorts, and a big phase of Iranians need the corrupt non secular regime gone. However regardless of Trump’s treacly protestations of sympathy with the courageous Iranian civilians whom he retains urging to rise and overthrow the ayatollahs, all indicators level to his willingness to desert them if he wants a fast exit from his new warfare.
It’s this side of Trump’s Iran warfare that hits me hardest within the intestine, as a result of I noticed it occur earlier than in Iraq.
In 1991, once I was protecting the primary Iraq Warfare, President George H.W. Bush known as for Iraqi Kurds and Shiites to revolt in opposition to Saddam Hussein (whose primarily Sunni followers managed Iraq), as the USA pushed into southern Iraq from liberated Kuwait. They adopted his name.
However Bush 41 selected to not proceed on to Baghdad and depose the Iraqi regime, as a result of his advisers warned this could set off an Iraqi civil warfare. Furthermore, he left a lot of Hussein’s military intact, together with their assault helicopters. Round 10,000 Shiites have been slaughtered; a number of hundred Kurds in Iraq’s north needed to flee into the freezing mountains in winter, till the U.S. Air Power established a no-fly zone over Iraqi Kurdistan they usually may return dwelling.
In February 2003, I crossed from Iran into Iraqi Kurdistan to await the invasion of Iraq by Bush 43, who claimed he needed to destroy the (non-existent) Iraqi nuclear program and produce democracy to the nation. On the time, it was onerous to not get swept up within the enthusiasm of Iraqi Kurds for the regime change the People have been promising in Baghdad.
America’s regional allies, particularly Israel, urged us to decapitate the Baghdad dictatorship — and White Home hawks insisted “regime change” would rapidly carry peace and democracy to the complete Mideast. So did exiled members of a number of Iraqi opposition teams, with whom I had been involved since protecting the 1991 Gulf Warfare.
Bush disbanded Iraq’s navy and fired a lot of its authorities. However he had no grasp of the advanced ethnic and spiritual politics of Iraq, which engulfed U.S. forces and created an inside Iraq civil warfare between Shiite and Sunni Muslims.
Quick ahead to Trump, who (at the very least for immediately) says his purpose isn’t regime change. He insists he is not going to put boots on the bottom and that the warfare will solely final a number of weeks.
Though Iran’s 86-year-old supreme chief, Ayatollah Khamenei, was killed by an Israeli airstrike, together with round 40 different Iranian leaders, that’s not more likely to finish the regime, however extra more likely to produce a military-backed dictatorship. Each side might have a breather in a number of weeks as Iranian missiles, and U.S. interceptors run quick.
However the president has already made clear he has little curiosity and no concrete plans for what ought to occur in Iran after the dying of its non secular leaders. Trump has upturned the well-known doctrine that the late Secretary of State Colin Powell utilized to 2003 Iraq, particularly “In case you break it, you personal it.” The Trump Doctrine posits: “We break it, you personal it. Goodbye and good luck.”
He has harassed that it’s as much as Iran’s folks to stand up and take over their nation, despite the fact that civilians are bereft of leaders, group, weapons and even web connections (and Reza Pahlavi, the exiled son of the final Shah, who hasn’t stepped foot in Iran for many years, has no armed forces of his personal).
Squeezed by the MAGA trustworthy, and keen on fast hits, Trump insists there shall be no long-term U.S. involvement. This may occasionally keep away from U.S. navy casualties however will most likely go away Iran in chaos, dominated by onerous males who nonetheless retain weapons.
That’s as a result of the strongest remaining navy drive in Iran is the hard-line Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps, which is deeply rooted all through the nation. Behind them are tons of of hundreds of Basij militiamen, who’ve proved able to kill demonstrators.
Trump has advised journalists he want to mannequin the Iran enterprise on the U.S. intervention in Venezuela, the place the highest chief, Nicolás Maduro, was kidnapped, and Trump then made a take care of his vice chairman. In Caracas, Trump eradicated a pacesetter he disliked, however saved the earlier regime, which in flip handed him management over Venezuelan oil.
Iran, nonetheless, couldn’t be extra completely different. Trump want to see the IRGC, or one faction, make a deal to completely eradicate Iran’s nuclear weapons program and missile manufacturing. The president advised journalists, apparently with regrets, that some potential new leaders had been killed within the bombing, and speculated that Iran’s future chief could possibly be “as dangerous” because the final.
Extra seemingly, the IRGC will struggle to the tip to take care of energy and gained’t be dislodged with out sending floor troops. It has proved keen to slaughter tens of hundreds of civilians to maintain energy and can be keen to take action once more.
I fear that Trump’s continued name for a civilian rebellion to “take over” Iran solely holds out the prospect that Iranian civilians will as soon as once more be slaughtered, whilst Trump chooses to declare victory and ship the fleet dwelling when missile interceptors run quick and his followers develop antsy. Israel could proceed bombing, however that gained’t assist Iranian protesters.
In an additional signal of how the administration could use and abuse Iranians, CNN reported that the CIA is arming Iranian Kurds to spark a wider rebellion vs. the regime (whilst Trump abandons Syrian Kurds, who helped U.S. forces struggle ISIS 10 years in the past, however now are of no extra use to him). Would Trump then abandon Iran’s Kurds if he determined to ink a pact with some IRGC normal whom he thought may turn into a versatile dictator of Iran?
For Trump, the Iran warfare is an exhibition of U.S. energy, designed to reinforce his imperial stature because the GOP faces dicey midterms and the Epstein hangover. For Iran’s folks, Trump’s actuality present is a life threatening matter. His “we break it, you repair it” doctrine may consign lots of them to dying.
©2026 The Philadelphia Inquirer, LLC. Go to at inquirer.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
