Doha, Qatar – The sight of plumes of smoke within the aftermath of Israeli bombings have develop into commonplace throughout the Center East in current months – however within the skyline of Qatar’s glitzy capital, it was wholly unprecedented.
Israel’s attack on Doha on Tuesday – the sixth nation it has attacked this 12 months – appeared to focus on the Palestinian group Hamas’s negotiating workforce, who have been speculated on the time to be getting ready to closing a ceasefire deal for Gaza.
Beneficial Tales
checklist of 4 objectsfinish of checklist
Qatar has performed host to truce negotiations all through the almost two-year battle, a number one mediator within the course of – by no means a combatant. It’s also a US ally, and the house of the US’s largest army base within the Center East.
Israel ignored red lines to stage its assault within the densely populated space of Qatar’s capital, situated close to international embassies and colleges, which killed five lower-ranked members of Hamas, in addition to a Qatari Inside Safety Power officer.
The attack has triggered a cascade of anger all through Qatar’s authorities, which has condemned it as “state terrorism” and a “reckless legal assault”.
“They see this as an act of cowardice and treachery,” Rashid al-Mohanadi, a nonresident fellow on the Center East Council on World Affairs, instructed Al Jazeera.
“Israel’s try to assassinate the [Hamas] negotiation workforce within the nation of the mediator reveals that the Israelis don’t have any seriousness in the case of reaching a [ceasefire] settlement.”
The assault has not solely known as into query how Qatar would possibly reply, but in addition the way forward for its well-established mediator position, in addition to its defence alliances.
“This assault might be one of many necessary historic shocks that may lead Qatar and different GCC [Gulf Cooperation Council] states to proceed their pursuit of diversified partnerships and [to] additional pursue strategic autonomy,” Sanam Vakil, the director of the Center East and North Africa Programme at Chatham Home, instructed Al Jazeera.
‘Straw that breaks the camel’s again’?
Qatar will possible leverage its position as a mediator in response to Israel’s assault, as its choices are restricted, in line with Cinzia Bianco, a visiting fellow on the European Council on International Relations.
“Its predominant leverage is to drag again from the position it has been enjoying for years … and use that as leverage to say, look, should you [do] not respect the neutrality of mediation, then you’ll be able to not depend on us to mediate for this battle,” Bianco instructed Al Jazeera.
Nevertheless, Bianco added, this might possible solely be helpful in pushing the US to behave, fairly than Israel, which seems to have little curiosity in agreeing to a ceasefire deal.
Qatar might additionally use financial strain towards Israel, mentioned al-Mohanadi.
“All choices are on the desk and financial strain will be imposed on the allies of Israel, specifically Europe and the US,” if they don’t take severe steps to cease Israel, al-Mohanadi mentioned. Qatar has billions of {dollars} value of investments in Europe and the US.
Vakil means that Arab states might use their diplomatic affect to induce Western allies to implement efficient constraints on Israel’s actions.
“Israel has struck seven international locations within the Center East, and hitting Qatar – I believe, [it] may very well be the straw that breaks the camel’s again for Israel,” she mentioned.
Vakil added that the Trump administration would possibly apply extra direct strain on Israel, which is in the end what Arab states, together with Qatar, hope to see to forestall additional safety threats.
Moreover, Qatar has the choice of going to the United Nations to diplomatically isolate Israel. An emergency UN Safety Council assembly will happen on Thursday in response to Israel’s assault, following requests from Algeria, Pakistan, and different nations, in line with diplomatic sources.
On Wednesday, Doha additionally introduced the creation of a authorized workforce headed by Qatari diplomat Mohammed bin Abdulaziz al-Khulaifi, “to take all authorized measures towards the treacherous Israeli assault, contemplating it an assault on the state’s sovereignty and a flagrant violation of worldwide regulation, conventions, and norms”.
Regardless of its restricted choices for a response, in al-Mohanadi’s view, Qatar is unlikely to desert its mediator position and can proceed to push for a ceasefire via the usage of multilateral organisations just like the UN Safety Council.
“Qatar won’t ever stop to be the mediator, as a result of mediation is actually in [Qatar’s] structure,” al-Mohanadi mentioned, including that the assault will solely be a “dent” within the position it has assumed in lots of conflicts for the previous decade.
Qatar has served as a mediator in varied worldwide conflicts, facilitating peace discussions within the Democratic Republic of the Congo, spearheading initiatives to reunite Ukrainian kids displaced by the Russian warfare, and appearing as an important middleman in Afghan peace and humanitarian negotiations by internet hosting talks with the Taliban.
Eleonora Ardemagni, a senior affiliate analysis fellow on the Italian Institute for Worldwide Political Research (ISPI), agrees that whereas there may be an “extraordinarily slim” window for Gaza ceasefire negotiations in the intervening time, Qatar will proceed to play its mediator position. US-Qatar ties, nevertheless, have been blighted by the assault.
“Qatar is conscious that it may well’t develop into the place the place different powers within the area settle accounts – that is about … nationwide safety,” Ardemagni instructed Al Jazeera.
“US deterrence is not capable of assure safety for Qatar, in addition to for the opposite GCC states.”
The strike, subsequently, leaves Qatar in a tough place in the case of hosting Hamas’s political leadership, mentioned the analysts.
“I don’t assume that we’re going to see a right away eviction of Hamas’s management – that would seem to point out weak point or [play] into Israel’s arms,” mentioned Vakil.
Qatar will fairly search for assurances from the US, provided that “Qatar supported Hamas with the blessing of america a few years in the past and with the blessing of Israel,” mentioned Vakil.
Qatari officers have repeatedly said that the choice to host the Hamas management got here after a request from the US.
In a 2023 opinion piece for The Wall Avenue Journal, the Qatari ambassador to the US, Sheikh Meshal bin Hamad Al Thani, mentioned that Washington needed the workplace “to ascertain oblique traces of communication with Hamas”.
Whereas the analysts concurred that Hamas management wouldn’t face fast expulsion from Doha, Bianco indicated there’s a “robust likelihood” Qatar will rethink internet hosting the group.
Following worldwide backlash after Hamas’s October 7, 2023, assault on Israel, Doha had already been evaluating this threat, however selected to take care of the connection to assist resolve the Gaza battle, she defined.
“But when the worth to be paid is that … they themselves develop into targets, I believe, [it will] most likely not [be] value it,” mentioned Bianco, noting that any relocation would possible be a coordinated, consensual switch of the group to a different location.
Safety diversification and gentle energy blows
Tuesday’s assault will possible speed up Qatar’s – and the broader Gulf international locations’ – pursuit of diversified safety preparations, in line with al-Mohanadi.
That would imply build up their very own collective defence capabilities or looking for safety partnerships with actors like China, he mentioned.
“What occurred yesterday was not [just a] breach on Qatar, it was a breach on all the GCC, which was at all times off limits,” mentioned the analyst.
The extent of this diversification will hinge on the US response to the assault, he added.
Nevertheless, as a serious non-NATO ally of the US, Qatar’s defence posture modifications will possible emerge progressively fairly than instantly, Vakil identified.
“There aren’t too many choices for Qatar for it to pivot and transfer elsewhere … Over the long run, Qatar will look to forge or diversify bilateral and multilateral relationships,” she defined.
The analysts predict Gulf international locations will unite over shared issues about regional destabilisation.
“With the Iranian assault towards Al Udeid first and now with the Israeli strike on Doha, one thing has modified within the notion that Gulf leaders have in regards to the future,” mentioned Ardemagni, referring to Iran’s attack in June on the Al Udeid airbase in Qatar, the biggest US army base within the Center East.
“There’s a rising sense of Gulf id and unity vis-a-vis exterior assaults. I see an increase of patriotism and the sense of [a] nationwide unity … amongst Qatari residents and residents.”
Whereas the analysts agree that Qatar’s worldwide investments – from London actual property holdings to possession of European soccer golf equipment – will stay unaffected, Israel’s actions have dealt a blow to Qatar’s home gentle energy ambitions.
“This assault is also an oblique aggression towards [Qatar’s] aspiration to develop into a vacationer hub and to carry extra worldwide occasions,” mentioned al-Mohanadi.
