Q. My spouse and I are lately retired and have a portfolio of about $2 million in dividend paying shares, pipelines, utilities and a few exchange-traded funds (ETFs) monitoring Canadian and U.S. excessive dividends shares in addition to S&P 500 and world fairness shares. We even have $900,000 in guaranteed investment certificates (GICs) and high-interest financial savings accounts (HISAs). We’re additionally lucky to have outlined profit pension plans and annuities producing about $100,000 in earnings per 12 months. My query is, what ought to I be doing with our investments at this level? We gained’t possible ever spend all this cash. We now have two very profitable sons and 5 grandchildren. We’d prefer to pay much less tax however who wouldn’t? Any ideas can be useful. —Thanks, Paul
FP Solutions: In case your objective is lowering your annual tax invoice, Paul, chances are you’ll profit from a method that makes use of asset location to information asset allocation. Asset location refers to holding investments in various kinds of accounts primarily based on how they’re taxed to shelter sure forms of earnings.
In your case, nevertheless, you didn’t point out holding registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) property, which isn’t unusual for retirees with giant outlined profit pension plans. With out registered accounts, conventional asset location methods grow to be considerably much less related if most of your investments are in taxable accounts. Typically talking, asset location tends to favour the next construction:
- Excessive-interest financial savings accounts and GICs are the least tax-efficient investments in non-registered accounts as a result of curiosity earnings is taxed at full marginal tax charges.
- Canadian dividend-paying shares are usually extra tax environment friendly in non-registered accounts as a result of dividend tax credit score, resulting in a diminished tax charge on Canadian dividends versus different earnings.
- U.S. dividend-paying shares generate international earnings, which can be taxed at full marginal tax charges like curiosity.
- Non-registered accounts profit from the preferential taxation of capital gains, together with the power to offset good points with capital losses.
- U.S. shares held in a tax-free savings account (TFSA) are topic to a 15 per cent withholding tax on dividends, which isn’t recoverable.
Based mostly on these dynamics, your GIC holdings are possible the least tax-efficient a part of your portfolio. That mentioned, that is considerably by design. Typically talking, the extra certainty an funding gives, by way of earnings or capital, the extra possible its earnings can be absolutely taxable. Pension earnings is an efficient instance. Whereas pension earnings is much less tax environment friendly than Canadian dividend earnings, the trade-off is the safety and predictability that comes from a long time of contributions and deferred tax financial savings throughout your working years.
With roughly $2 million invested in world shares and $900,000 in money equivalents, your general portfolio allocation is roughly 70 per cent shares and 30 per cent money or money equivalents. Portfolios on this vary are usually thought of balanced development or growth-oriented portfolios.
As a result of we must always not let the tax tail wag the canine, it could not make sense to shift GICs into shares solely for tax benefits if taking over extra danger is pointless. In truth, holding a significant money allocation has grow to be more and more fashionable in recent times. Many buyers have most popular money over conventional bonds, notably after world bond markets skilled double-digit declines in 2022. HISAs and GICs even have rates of interest which can be akin to bond yields at the moment.
Reviewing your annual spending wants ought to assist decide whether or not portfolio changes are vital for sensible money circulation functions or just to enhance tax effectivity. However your reference to “dividend paying shares” deserves some consideration. If you’re biased towards shares that pay dividends, you might be incomes extra of your return from earnings taxable yearly versus capital development. Holding a inventory that pays a decrease dividend which will earn extra of its return from inventory value appreciation over time could also be extra tax environment friendly. Particularly if you’re a buy-and-hold investor dwelling largely off your pensions.
Tax planning for retirees usually entails balancing the advantages of realizing taxable earnings right this moment in opposition to leaving deferred taxes to the property in a while. Rebalancing a non-registered portfolio incessantly entails triggering capital good points or losses, so bettering portfolio effectivity may additionally imply steadily addressing unrealized good points over time.
One method is a partial “meltdown” technique, the place capital good points are deliberately triggered annually to scale back the long run tax burden on the property. In case your unrealized good points are substantial, it could take a number of years to reposition the portfolio with out materially growing annual taxes.
Extra tax effectivity may additionally be attainable relying on how funding earnings is cut up between you and your spouse. In case your investments are collectively owned and earnings is already being reported evenly, notably in case your pension incomes are additionally comparable or eligible for pension earnings splitting, you might be possible already working pretty effectively from an income-splitting perspective.
If one partner has materially decrease earnings, nevertheless, it could make sense for that partner to reinvest their after-tax earnings into accounts held beneficially in their very own title, whereas the higher-income partner assumes a larger share of family bills with withdrawals from their accounts.
Because you talked about that you’re unlikely to spend all your property, an alternative choice is to deliberately enhance spending throughout retirement. Doing so naturally reduces future property worth whereas permitting you to get pleasure from extra of your wealth throughout your lifetime.
You can additionally think about gifting funds to your grownup youngsters, which typically doesn’t set off any tax points in Canada aside from tax on capital good points. A present itself isn’t taxable, nevertheless. Aiding with registered training financial savings plans (RESPs) or in-trust accounts in your grandchildren may additionally assist assist future training or monetary objectives if that has not already been explored.
Lastly, charitable giving stays one of the crucial efficient methods to scale back taxes in retirement. Donations generate invaluable tax credit and donating appreciated securities straight may be particularly tax environment friendly. By transferring securities in type you possibly can keep away from triggering capital good points tax whereas nonetheless receiving a charitable receipt for the complete market worth of the donation.
General, your scenario seems much less about maximizing returns and extra about balancing tax effectivity, property planning, household objectives and private consolation with danger — which is a lucky place to be in, Paul.
Andrew Dobson is a fee-only, advice-only licensed monetary planner (CFP) and chartered funding supervisor (CIM) at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in London, Ont. He doesn’t promote any monetary merchandise in anyway. He may be reached at adobson@objectivecfp.com.
Do you’ve gotten a query for FP Solutions? Electronic mail wealth@postmedia.com.
