Seattle College college students returning to campus this 12 months have been shocked to find that their native Entire Meals retailer had shut its doorways over the summer time. Some college students have been dismayed by the lack of this off-campus hang-out at Broadway and East Madison Avenue, mourning the disappearance of the triple-berry Chantilly cake, hot-bar dinners and pizza by the slice.
However as I walked previous the “Area for Hire” indicators plastered throughout its home windows, I felt no grief. As an alternative, I puzzled if this empty area may very well be a possibility for one thing a lot better: a grocery retailer that common individuals can really afford.
Entire Meals was the top of convenience-meets-luxury. The stands overflowing with recent seasonal produce. Limitless aisles adorned with aromatics like natural cleaning soap, recent baked items and handcrafted bouquets.
That sounds good, and it smelled good, too. However the costs have been astronomical. Entire Meals was not designed to fulfill the on a regular basis wants of most Seattle residents, together with college students like me. The Seattle College Meals Pantry studies that it receives a mean of 150 requests from college students per week for meals from its personal college students and school.
In a metropolis the place so many wrestle to afford groceries, individuals don’t want curated, artisanal picks. They want dependable entry to high quality, nourishing, inexpensive meals. Addressing this pressing want means reimagining how we offer important sources, starting with a public method to grocery shops.
There’s excellent news for Seattle: Mayor-elect Katie Wilson has promised to discover a “public possibility” for grocery shops, particularly in meals deserts — areas with restricted entry to recent, inexpensive meals. Whereas Wilson has not pointed to a particular mannequin, she has expressed assist for each publicly owned and operated grocery shops and metropolis partnerships with nonprofit-run shops. Now, she have to be held to her promise. Wilson’s marketing campaign prioritized fixing Seattle’s affordability disaster. Her message of change, progressivism and community-inspired options is why she was elected.
Seattle wants a transformative answer to make sure meals entry for all. One method may very well be a public grocery retailer, run by a government-nonprofit partnership, the place costs are set 25% to 30% decrease than company alternate options. As a result of these city-owned shops could also be eligible for breaks on property taxes or lease that usually burden for-profit shops, they will promote groceries at wholesale costs. Public grocery shops deal with meals as a public good and as a necessity that each particular person deserves, fairly than a way of revenue.
Different cities, similar to Chicago and Madison, Wis., are planning or experimenting with approaches. Typical public grocery shops comply with a public-private partnership mannequin: In Atlanta, for instance, authorities businesses oversee funding and property possession, whereas personal operators handle the shops. New York Metropolis Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani has additionally pledged to open public grocery shops — although, like Wilson, he has but to announce a particular enterprise mannequin.
Public grocery shops face criticism for his or her potential to burden taxpayers and undercut small grocers. However, as with all meals safety insurance policies, these issues have to be weighed in opposition to the advantages, particularly when present fashions and packages have failed to fulfill the neighborhood’s primary wants.
Black, Indigenous and low-income Seattleites endure disproportionately excessive charges of meals insecurity. In 2024, town of Seattle reported that roughly 10% of grownup residents don’t have sufficient to eat, with households of colour twice as prone to be affected. In South Seattle, practically 25% of residents report battling meals insecurity, worsened by excessive grocery costs and retailer closures.
Public grocery shops provide a brand new and hopeful method to meals entry. These shops would supply dependable, inexpensive, healthful meals and make sure that starvation isn’t a barrier to scholar success, whether or not that scholar is in kindergarten or in school. Each particular person deserves reliable entry to wholesome nourishment. That sounds higher than simply strolling by and smelling these Entire Meals pastries … proper?
Editor’s word: Feedback have been disabled on this op-ed as a result of too many posts violated our phrases of service, notably the rule prohibiting name-calling.
